Public Access
feat(ui): explicit Deny semantics with 2-denial hard-filter escalation (Sprint 8)
User policy decision (2026-06-05, exact): 'Hard filter. If it is denied
this week twice, it should be considered denied for good.'
The planner had no cross-week memory of denials: a denial on
meal_plan_item.approval_status was never consulted by the planner,
and NeverSuggest (the per-family permanent blocklist) was empty for
the user. The 'Roasted Sweet Potato and Chickpea Bowl' the user
denied on 2026-05-15 was still in the planner's pool 3 weeks
later.
Implements C + Z (explicit two-button model + soft-decay +
hard-filter escalation):
- Approve: untouched.
- Deny this week (1st in 90d): denial_expires_at = now() + 90d.
- Deny this week (2nd in 90d, server-side auto-escalation):
denial_expires_at = NULL + a NeverSuggest row written.
- Never again (explicit): same as the 2nd-time auto-escalation.
Both soft and permanent denials are hard filters in the planner
(per user). A denied recipe never reappears until either the 90d
window expires or the user un-blocks via the NeverSuggest API.
Changes:
- Migration 0016: meal_plan_item.denial_expires_at (partial index)
and meal_plan_vote.denial_scope.
- 3 backend helpers (_apply_denial, _ensure_never_suggest_recipe,
_has_prior_active_soft_denial) — single source of truth for the
deny path.
- POST /api/meals/items/{id}/deny?scope=this_week|never_again
(default this_week). Returns promoted_to_permanent.
- POST /api/meals/vote/{id} extended: vote=approve|deny|never_again.
Returns denial_scope + promoted_to_permanent.
- GET /api/meals/vote/{id} HTML page renders 3 buttons; supports
one-click ?scope=... for email direct-action links.
- Email template (step_email): 3 direct-action links per recipe
plus a secondary 'open vote page' link.
- Planner: _load_blocklists returns 3 sets; soft_denied_recipes
is hard-filtered (union with blocked_recipes at the call site).
- Frontend: MealCard renders 3 buttons (Approve / Deny this week
/ Never again) for pending items. handleDeny is scope-aware;
toast reflects promoted_to_permanent. window.confirm on
'Never again' prevents accidental permanent blocks.
Verification:
- npm run build green.
- 21/21 planner tests pass (1 pre-existing test_filter_blocks_by_cost
failure is NOT introduced by Sprint 8 — verified via git stash).
- Review/sprint8-verification.md: 11-step browser smoke + 4 API
curls + email-render procedure + rollback.
Files:
- backend/alembic/versions/0016_denial_decay_and_scope.py (new)
- backend/app/models/__init__.py:221-242, 250-269
- backend/app/schemas/__init__.py:204-219, 248-269
- backend/app/api/meals.py:30-138 (helpers), 240-330 (HTML page),
380-455 (submit_vote), 486-552 (deny_meal_item)
- backend/app/services/orchestrator/steps.py:283-300
- backend/app/services/planner/generate.py:59-99, 150-194
- frontend/src/api/index.ts:48-58
- frontend/src/pages/Dashboard.tsx:38-50, 385-410
- Review/{sprint8-verification,ui-nielsen-audit,handoff-ui-audit}.md
- fix-ui-audit.md
- docs/HANDOFF.md
- .agent/{plan,context}.md
Deploy (user runs on deployment host):
cd ~/MealPlanner && git pull
docker compose exec backend alembic upgrade head
docker compose -f docker-compose.yml up -d --build backend frontend
This commit is contained in:
@@ -2,7 +2,30 @@
|
||||
|
||||
You are taking over a 6-sprint UI/UX audit and fix cycle. All code changes are committed and build green. The user's deployment host (Tailscale `100.108.224.12`) is the only environment you should touch for verification — the local repo on this machine (`/home/peter/Projects/MealPlanner`) was the editing host; the running app lives elsewhere.
|
||||
|
||||
**Date of handoff: 2026-06-04. Last updated: 2026-06-05 (Sprint 7 in progress).**
|
||||
**Date of handoff: 2026-06-04. Last updated: 2026-06-05 (Sprint 8 in progress).**
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
## ⚠️ Active sprint: Sprint 8 — "Deny" semantics (C + Z, hard-filter escalation)
|
||||
|
||||
**Status: in progress. User approved on 2026-06-05. Code not yet committed.**
|
||||
|
||||
**User policy decision (2026-06-05, exact words):** "Hard filter. If it is denied this week twice, it should be considered denied for good."
|
||||
|
||||
**Root cause (one-liner):** the planner has no cross-week memory of denials. Denials live on the `meal_plan_item` row, are never consulted by the planner, and the `NeverSuggest` blocklist is empty for the user's family. The user's "Roasted Sweet Potato and Chickpea Bowl" was denied on 2026-05-15 but the recipe was still in the pool for the next 90+ days.
|
||||
|
||||
**Policy (Sprint 8):**
|
||||
|
||||
- "Approve" → `item.approval_status = approved`. n/a.
|
||||
- "Deny this week" (1st in 90d) → `denied` + `denial_expires_at = now() + 90d`. Recipe becomes eligible again after 90d.
|
||||
- "Deny this week" (2nd in 90d — **server-side auto-escalation**) → `denied` + `denial_expires_at = NULL` + a `NeverSuggest` row written. Permanent.
|
||||
- "Never again" (explicit) → same as the 2nd-time auto-escalation. Permanent.
|
||||
|
||||
**Scope (12 boxes):** see `.agent/plan.md` "Active sprint" section. Code changes are M-L: 1 migration, 2 model columns, 2 schema fields, 3 backend helpers, 2 endpoint extensions, 1 planner update, 1 email template update, 1 webui MealCard update. **No new dependencies. Migration 0016 required.**
|
||||
|
||||
**Tracking docs:** `Review/sprint8-verification.md` (deploy + smoke), `Review/ui-nielsen-audit.md` Sprint 8 status block, `fix-ui-audit.md` T2.1–T2.10, `Review/handoff-ui-audit.md` (this file), `docs/HANDOFF.md` Sprint 8 section.
|
||||
|
||||
**Thread 3 (§Future backlog) is deferred** until S8 is deployed + verified. F1 onboarding, F8/F9 proposals, dead `Generate Meal Plan` CTA at `Dashboard.tsx:415`.
|
||||
|
||||
---
|
||||
|
||||
@@ -278,4 +301,4 @@ cd frontend && npm run build
|
||||
|
||||
Trust the build output. Trust the smoke checklist. Don't trust the deployment host's UI until the user confirms. The verification model is "I shipped, you verified, you reported, I fixed" — the agent in this role never sees the live UI directly.
|
||||
|
||||
**Last updated: 2026-06-05** — Sprints 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 deployed-or-awaiting-deploy; **Sprint 7 (webui empty-meal-plan fix) in progress**. See the "Active sprint" callout at the top of this file for the current state.
|
||||
**Last updated: 2026-06-05** — Sprints 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 deployed-or-awaiting-deploy; Sprint 7 (webui empty-meal-plan fix) **committed `09c7525` awaiting user deploy**; **Sprint 8 (Deny semantics C + Z with hard-filter escalation) in progress**. See the "Active sprint" callout at the top of this file for the current state.
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user